Arbitration vs. Mediation
Arbitration is also termed as ADR (alternative dispute resolution) where the conflicts or disputes are resolves outside the court. Whereas mediation can be termed as an assisted negotiation and communication between two parties for reaching a certain agreement. Arbitrations are considered as consensual which means that it only takes place when both parties agree over it. Moreover both arbitration and mediation are used in conjunction with litigation process where any one of the opposing parties can communicate and give it their fullest and when it fails then the next step is to go for a trial. If we look upon mediation, it is a non-binding process while arbitration is a binding process. Arbitration involves a single or multiple arbitrators/panel of arbitrators while on the other hand in mediation there is an involvement of only one mediator. So when the decision is made in the presence multiple arbitrators then it is done on the basis of the vote and in the situation where there is a mediator the resolution is made by looking up to the facts through communication and negotiation. Moreover arbitration is like a less formal court but more formal than of process mediation, as the arbitrator can be a professional engineer etc. or can be a retired judge or even a senior lawyer. And the parties present their cases outside the court and in the end the arbitrator has the power to give a legal binding decision which they have to follow and if not then it can be enforced. Whereas in mediation the process of negotiation is handled much more informally and flexibly with the help of the mediator. Here the dispute is discussed with the parties and it is discussed a million time among them until and unless a mutual decision is reached and once it had then the parties often make a written statement of it. In short the function of the mediator is to facilitate the discussion or the negotiation while the arbitrator renders a decision. Furthermore mediation is cost-effective, more efficient and reduced trials. While arbitration is an expensive, mostly inefficient, time-consuming and a less reliable process.
Key Differences
Formal process of reaching to a decision; mediation is not at all a formal process.
Arbitration can be done voluntarily and by compulsion; mediation is voluntarily done.
There can be one or a panel of arbitrators; mediation includes only one mediator;
Mediator has the role of facilitating the negotiation process while the arbitrator makes a decision regarding the matter.
Janet White
May 22, 2016
The parties in arbitration have to agree with the decision made by the arbitrator as the matter is handed over to him; in mediation the decision is made collectively and collaboratively with the help of the mediator.
The person is the arbitrator must have expertise and legal training while it is not necessary for a mediator.
Aimie Carlson
May 22, 2016
ADVERTISEMENT
The decision made by the arbitrator can be essential and has the chances of leading further into litigation in case of a panel; mediation is the process where the mediator chosen by the parties usually has a significant impact on the final decision.
Aimie Carlson
May 22, 2016
Comparison Chart
.
When some parties have a dispute then it is handed over to an arbitrator who can be retired judge
It is a very simple and informal process where assisted negotiation for a certain agreement is done.
Work
Can be done voluntarily and by compulsion
Always done voluntarily
Decision
Parties in arbitration have to agree with the decision made by the arbitrator
Decision is made collectively and collaboratively with the help of the mediator.
Arbitration and Mediation Definitions
Arbitration
The process by which the parties to a dispute submit their differences to the judgment of an impartial person or group appointed by mutual consent or statutory provision.
Mediation
To resolve or settle (differences) by working with all the conflicting parties
Mediate a labor-management dispute.
ADVERTISEMENT
Arbitration
The act or process of arbitrating.
Mediation
To bring about (a settlement, for example) by working with all the conflicting parties.
Arbitration
A process through which two or more parties use an arbitrator or arbiter in order to resolve a dispute.
Mediation
To effect or convey as an intermediate agent or mechanism
Chemicals that mediate inflammation.
Arbitration
In general, a form of justice where both parties designate a person whose ruling they will accept formally. More specifically in Market Anarchist (market anarchy) theory, arbitration designates the process by which two agencies pre-negotiate a set of common rules in anticipation of cases where a customer from each agency is involved in a dispute.
Mediation
(Physics) To convey (a force) between subatomic particles.
ADVERTISEMENT
Arbitration
The hearing and determination of a cause between parties in controversy, by a person or persons chosen by the parties.
Mediation
To work with two or more disputants in order to bring about an agreement, settlement, or compromise.
Arbitration
(law) the hearing and determination of a dispute by an impartial referee agreed to by both parties (often used to settle disputes between labor and management)
Mediation
To settle or reconcile differences
"[George] Eliot's effort to mediate between the conflicting demands of representation and readability in the [novel's] dialect usage" (Carol A. Martin).
Arbitration
The act of deciding as an arbiter; giving authoritative judgment;
They submitted their disagreement to arbitration
Mediation
To have a relation to two differing persons, groups, or things
Psychological processes that mediate between stimulus and response.
Mediation
Acting through, involving, or dependent on an intervening agency.
Mediation
Being in a middle position.
Mediation
Negotiation to resolve differences conducted by an impartial party.
Mediation
The act of intervening for the purpose of bringing about a settlement.
Mediation
(Gallicism) heritage interpretation
Mediation
The act of mediating; action or relation of anything interposed; action as a necessary condition, means, or instrument; interposition; intervention.
The soul [acts] by the mediation of these passions.
Mediation
Hence, specifically, agency between parties at variance, with a view to reconcile them; entreaty for another; intercession.
Mediation
Negotiation to resolve differences conducted by some impartial party
Mediation
The act of mediating
Definition of Arbitration
When some parties have a dispute then it is handed over to an arbitrator who can be retired judge or a senior lawyer etc. who then gives a binding decision which they have to follow. It is a less formal process but not completely informal. The arbitration in consensual and the parties has the choice of choosing their sole arbitrators i.e. there can be a total of more than one arbitrator. The whole process of arbitration is confidential and conducted neutrally.
Definition of Mediation
It is a very simple and informal process where assisted negotiation for a certain agreement is done. It is voluntary that the parties can leave anytime they want to no matter what the reason. Additionally it is a negotiation which is done collaboratively as none can impose decisions on anyone. The participants have the decision making authority but only through negotiation as nothing can be imposed but in the end the decisions made are satisfying and informed as equal participation is taken. And it is the role of the mediator to make sure that the agreements are reached in a knowledgeable manner, so none in the end is left unknown about any fact. Furthermore, the mediator here is a single mediator who is balanced, neutral, safe, and impartial.
