Difference Wiki

Constitutional Government vs. Non-Constitutional Government: What's the Difference?

Edited by Janet White || By Harlon Moss || Updated on October 9, 2023
Constitutional government operates per a codified set of rules, while non-constitutional government does not adhere to a formalized constitution.

Key Differences

In the context of a constitutional government, a written or unwritten constitution is a paramount document that dictates the structure and operational norms of the government. This form of government is bound by legal frameworks, ensuring that every action undertaken adheres to established laws and statutes. A non-constitutional government, on the other hand, lacks a central, authoritative document that delineates the structure, roles, and responsibilities of governing bodies and officials.
Constitutional governments tend to emphasize a separation of powers among the legislative, executive, and judicial branches. Such a division is intended to prevent the abuse of power and safeguard democratic principles and individual liberties. In contrast, non-constitutional governments often witness an aggregation of power, which may be centralized in a single individual or a select group, often without explicit legal frameworks to delineate or restrain that power.
In a constitutional government, citizens typically enjoy defined rights and freedoms, safeguarded by the constitution, which can serve as a buffer against arbitrary rule and provide mechanisms for accountability and redress. Conversely, in a non-constitutional government, the rights and freedoms of the citizens may be subject to the whims of the ruling power, with potentially limited avenues for accountability or redress.
Further, constitutional governments usually possess mechanisms for amendment, allowing the constitution to evolve in response to societal changes and needs. Non-constitutional governments may change rules or procedures at the discretion of the ruling authority, potentially leading to unstable or unpredictable governing practices.
In international relations, constitutional governments often engage differently with global entities and norms compared to non-constitutional governments. The former may employ a consistent approach rooted in their constitutional frameworks, while the latter may navigate international affairs based on the immediate interests and preferences of the ruling authority.

Comparison Chart

Basis of Operation

Operates based on a defined constitution.
Operates without a formal constitution.

Legal Framework

Has a clear, codified legal framework.
May lack a codified legal framework.

Citizen’s Rights

Ensures defined rights for citizens.
Rights of citizens may not be guaranteed.

Accountability Mechanisms

Contains mechanisms for government accountability.
May lack clear accountability mechanisms.

Amendment Procedures

Has procedures to amend the constitution.
Rule changes can be arbitrary.

Constitutional Government and Non-Constitutional Government Definitions

Constitutional Government

It ensures the separation of powers among different branches of government.
The constitutional government of France divides power among the executive, legislative, and judicial branches.

Non-Constitutional Government

Citizens’ rights might not be explicitly defined or protected.
Under the non-constitutional government of ancient Egypt, citizens’ rights were subject to pharaohs’ rulings.

Constitutional Government

A constitutional government safeguards citizens' rights through established legal frameworks.
Canada’s constitutional government protects citizens’ rights through the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.

Non-Constitutional Government

It does not guarantee a separation of power and may centralize authority.
Historical monarchies often exemplify non-constitutional government with centralized authority.

Constitutional Government

A constitutional government adheres to a recognized constitution that regulates its operations.
The United States is a constitutional government with a written document delineating the nation's foundational laws and principles.

Non-Constitutional Government

It may engage in international affairs without a consistent foundational policy basis.
The non-constitutional government in historical fascist regimes often navigated foreign affairs based on immediate leadership interests.

Constitutional Government

It incorporates mechanisms for amendments and modifications of the governing document.
India's constitutional government allows for amendments to be made to its constitution, enabling adaptability to changing needs.

Non-Constitutional Government

A non-constitutional government operates without a governing constitution.
Saudi Arabia functions as a non-constitutional government, where a formal, codified constitution is absent.

Constitutional Government

A constitutional government often engages in international affairs with a basis in its codified principles.
Germany, as a constitutional government, conducts foreign policy while adhering to principles outlined in its Basic Law.

Non-Constitutional Government

A non-constitutional government might establish laws and practices at the discretion of the ruling power.
The non-constitutional government of North Korea enables the enactment of laws at the leader's discretion.


How are citizens’ rights protected in a constitutional government?

A constitutional government protects citizens’ rights through legal frameworks and protections embedded within the constitution.

How does a non-constitutional government operate?

A non-constitutional government functions without adherence to a formal, authoritative constitution, often centralizing power and authority.

Is power centralized in non-constitutional governments?

Generally, yes. Non-constitutional governments tend to centralize power, lacking distinct separations or checks and balances among different branches.

What is a constitutional government?

A constitutional government operates according to a defined, written or unwritten, constitution that prescribes the structure and function of the government.

Are all democratic governments constitutional?

While most democracies operate under a constitution to safeguard freedoms and ensure accountability, the terms are not synonymous, and variations exist.

Can a monarchy be a constitutional government?

Yes, a monarchy can be constitutional if it operates under a constitution, like the United Kingdom, where the monarch's powers are regulated.

Can constitutional governments vary in their structures?

Yes, constitutional governments can exhibit varied structures, reflecting differing approaches to power separation, rights protection, and governance.

What ensures the separation of powers in a constitutional government?

The constitution explicitly segregates governmental powers into distinct branches (typically legislative, executive, and judicial) to prevent power abuse.

How does a constitutional government respond to constitutional violations?

Constitutional governments typically employ judicial mechanisms to adjudicate and resolve instances of constitutional violations, ensuring adherence to the document.

Can a constitution be amended in a constitutional government?

Yes, constitutional governments have formal processes for amending the constitution to adapt to societal changes or needs.

How flexible is the legal framework in non-constitutional governments?

Non-constitutional governments may exhibit highly flexible legal frameworks, enabling rule creation or modification at the discretion of the ruling authority.

How does rule of law function in constitutional governments?

In constitutional governments, the rule of law is paramount, ensuring all individuals and entities are subject to and accountable under the law.

What is a fundamental right within a constitutional government?

Fundamental rights in constitutional governments are basic, protected freedoms and entitlements, such as freedom of speech or religion, entrenched in the constitution.

Are leaders in non-constitutional governments always dictators?

Not necessarily. While dictatorial rule can exist in non-constitutional settings, other leadership forms, like oligarchies or monarchies, might also be present.

Can a non-constitutional government uphold the rule of law?

A non-constitutional government can uphold rule of law, but it is often subject to the desires and whims of the ruling authority without a foundational legal document.

How stable are citizens' rights in non-constitutional governments?

In non-constitutional governments, citizens' rights might be unstable and subject to the whims or immediate decisions of the ruling authority.

What role does a constitution play in shaping a nation’s international relations?

In constitutional governments, international relations and foreign policies are often shaped and guided by the principles and statutes within the constitution.

How do non-constitutional governments navigate international relations?

Non-constitutional governments navigate international relations based often on immediate leadership interests without necessarily adhering to a stable, foundational policy basis.

How is justice administered in non-constitutional governments?

In non-constitutional governments, justice may be administered per the ruling authority’s decisions, possibly lacking standardized or predictable judicial mechanisms.

Are non-constitutional governments inherently oppressive?

Not inherently. While some non-constitutional governments can be oppressive, others may exhibit benevolent or paternalistic characteristics, albeit without a codifying constitution.
About Author
Written by
Harlon Moss
Harlon is a seasoned quality moderator and accomplished content writer for Difference Wiki. An alumnus of the prestigious University of California, he earned his degree in Computer Science. Leveraging his academic background, Harlon brings a meticulous and informed perspective to his work, ensuring content accuracy and excellence.
Edited by
Janet White
Janet White has been an esteemed writer and blogger for Difference Wiki. Holding a Master's degree in Science and Medical Journalism from the prestigious Boston University, she has consistently demonstrated her expertise and passion for her field. When she's not immersed in her work, Janet relishes her time exercising, delving into a good book, and cherishing moments with friends and family.

Trending Comparisons

Popular Comparisons

New Comparisons