Food

Difference Between Ribeye and New York Strip

ADVERTISEMENT
CONTINUE READING BELOW

Main Difference

The main difference between Ribeye and New York Strip is that Ribeye comes from the rib area of the cow, whereas the New York Strip comes from the loin area of the cow.

Ribeye vs. New York Strip

The Ribeye is available as boneless or a bone-in, while the New York Strip is only available as a boneless portion. Ribeye can also be known as Delmonico, Beauty Steak, Scotch Fillet, Market Steak, Spencer; on the other hand, the New York Strip is also known as Sirloin Steak, Porterhouse, and Kansas City Steak.

Ribeye is more tender and fattier than other steaks; on the flip side, the New York Strip is a bit hard as compare to the ribeye. Ribeye originates from the rib area of the cow, whereas the New York Strip originates from the loin area of the cow.

ADVERTISEMENT
CONTINUE READING BELOW

The Ribeye contains significantly more fat content or internal marbling; on the flip side, the New York Strip consists of less fat content. Ribeye contains 190 C, 4g saturated fats, and 23g proteins; on the contrary, the New York Strip consists of 160 C, 2.3 g saturated fats, and 25g proteins.

The Ribeye is usually well known and most demanding because of its deep marbling and rich in flavor. In contrast, the New York Strip contains more tenderness and more chewing characteristics with having a thick pack of fat in its one downside. When the Ribeye is cooked properly, the fatty steak which it contains then melt in the mouth, while the thickness of the New York Strip helps it from drying and getting rough when coking.

ADVERTISEMENT

Comparison Chart

RibeyeNew York Strip
Ribeye is a beefsteak that usually cut from the rib part of the cow and also called Rib Eye.New York Strip called so due to its connotation with the new York city, and it is also a beefsteak that usually cut from the loin part of the cow.
Availability
Available as boneless or a bone-inOnly available as boneless portion
Other Names
Delmonico, Beauty Steak, Scotch Fillet, Market Steak, SpencerSirloin Steak, Porterhouse, and Kansas City Steak
Tenderness
More tender and fattier than strips of about 4gA bit hardy as compare to the Ribeye
Source
Originates from the rib area of the cowOriginates from the loin area of the cow
Fat Content
Contains significantly more fat content or internal marblingConsist of less fat content
Nutritional Value
Contains 190 C, 4g saturated fats, and 23g proteinsConsist of 160 C, 2.3 g saturated fats, and 25g proteins
Characteristics
Usually well known and most demanding because of its deep marbling and rich in flavorContains more tenderness and more chewing characteristic with having a thick pack of fat in its one downside
Cooking
When cooked properly, the fatty steak which it contains then melt in the mouthThe thickness helps it from drying and getting rough when coking
ADVERTISEMENT

What is Ribeye?

Ribeye is the beefsteak, which is also called as Rib Eye, usually originates from the rib section of the cow. Furthermore, the Ribeye steaks are made of longissimus dorsi muscle of the cow. Though, ribeye steaks also contain the complexus muscles and spinal.

The Ribeye contains some variants. When the beef steak is cut off from the primal rib of the cow and the rib bone is still attached to the meat, then it will be known as rib steak. When the beef steak consists of removed bone, then it will be known as a spencer steak or an eye steak.

The Ribeye contains the most significant amount of marbling of fat. So, Ribeye is considered as the juiciest or rich in flavor steak of all the steaks. The Ribeye could be boneless or may be bone-in steaks.

Moreover, the meat coming from the rib portion is deliberated to be very tender of all the strips. The rib portion of the cow lacks exercise, so it consists of more fat content. The fat marbling helps in high and fast cooking. The best portion of the Ribeye is the boneless portion, though many people prefer the bone-in portion because bones add to the rich flavor in the steak.

Many other names for Ribeye are Beauty Steaks, Delmonico, Market Steaks, and Spencer. The Ribeye is mostly known for the rich flavor and deep marbling. The fatty streaks in the Ribeye become melt in the mouth when it is cooked properly.

What is New York Strip?

The word New York Strip is because of the city New York from which it is related because New York is extensively referred to as strip steak. The steaks from this portion contain muscles that perform the little exercise and do functions, so those muscles are called the longissimus.

The New York Strip is marketed under many names, as said by Cattlemen’s Beef Association. The different names for New York strips are Veiny Steak, Top Loin, Hotel-Style Steak, Ambassador Steak, Boneless Club Steak, and Kansas City Steak. In many other countries, the name for the New York Strip varies according to the per country.

In the variation of the New York Strip, if the steak strip is attached to the bone and still contains the piece of tenderloin, then it will call as T-bone steak or porterhouse steak. The difference between T-bone steak and porterhouse is that porterhouse has a larger portion of tenderloin.

The New York Strip contains less fat as compared to the ribeye and almost tender. The New York Strip is only found boneless, so it has a flavor of all of its own, which is buttery and succulent. Some New York Strips also come in the bone-in formation such as porterhouse.

Key Differences

  1. Ribeye is cut off from the rib portion of the cow, while the New York Strip is cut off from the loin portion of the cow.
  2. Ribeye has more tenderness; on the other hand, the New York Strip is usually a bit hardy.
  3. The Ribeye contains a considerable amount of more fat content; on the contrary, the New York Strip contains a low amount of fat content.
  4. In nutritional value, the Ribeye contains 190 C, 4g saturated fats, and 23g proteins; on the flip side, the New York Strip contains 160 C, 2.3 g saturated fats, and 25g proteins.
  5. The Ribeye is mainly available as boneless or bone-in; on the other hand, the New York Strip is only available as boneless.
  6. The fatty steak which Ribeye contains becomes melt in the mouth and rich in flavor when it cooks; on the other hand, when New York Strip cooks, the fatness of the New York Strip helps it from parching and getting uneven.
  7. When buying Ribeye, it is easily available in the butcher shops and all supermarkets; on the flip side, the New York Strip could only be delivered from the Snake River Farms as it contains less marbling.
  8. The Ribeye is less healthy as compare to the New York Strip because Ribeye contains more saturated fats, but the New York Strip contains less saturated fats, and it also delivers more proteins.

Conclusion

The above discussion concludes that both are beef steaks, but Ribeye comes from the rib portion of the cow, and the New York Strip comes from the loin part of the cow. The Ribeye is more tender as compared to the New York Strip.

Aimie Carlson

Aimie Carlson is an English language enthusiast who loves writing and has a master degree in English literature. Follow her on Twitter at @AimieCarlson

Adblocker detected! Please consider reading this notice.

We've detected that you are using AdBlock Plus or some other adblocking software which is preventing the page from fully loading.

We don't have any banner, Flash, animation, obnoxious sound, or popup ad. We do not implement these annoying types of ads!

We need money to operate the site, and almost all of it comes from our online advertising.

Please add difference.wiki to your ad blocking whitelist or disable your adblocking software.

×