Physicalism vs. Idealism: What's the Difference?
Edited by Aimie Carlson || By Janet White || Updated on September 27, 2023
Physicalism posits that everything is physical or material, while Idealism asserts that reality is fundamentally mental or spiritual.
Key Differences
Physicalism and Idealism are two contrasting philosophical positions that offer different answers to the nature of reality. Physicalism, in its most basic form, holds that the only true reality consists of physical entities. It contends that everything, including consciousness and thoughts, can be reduced to physical properties. In contrast, Idealism argues that reality is fundamentally grounded in mental or spiritual entities, suggesting that ideas or consciousness are primary over the physical world.
Physicalism often aligns with empirical and scientific viewpoints. Physicalists assert that the world is composed of material objects and that even mental states have physical bases, often tied to brain activity. Idealism, conversely, posits that reality is constructed by mental activities. For idealists, the mind is central, and the physical world is either a manifestation of mental constructs or secondary in importance.
In debates about the nature of consciousness, the divide between Physicalism and Idealism becomes evident. While Physicalists might argue that consciousness arises from the complexities of brain functions, Idealists may posit that consciousness is a fundamental aspect of reality, with the physical world being a derivative or projection of conscious experience.
Historically, these positions have been foundational in philosophical discourse. Physicalism has gained traction with the rise of scientific methodology, emphasizing tangible, measurable phenomena. Meanwhile, Idealism has its roots in older philosophical traditions, with figures like Plato and George Berkeley asserting the primacy of ideas or mental entities over the material world.
Comparison Chart
Nature of Reality
Everything is physical.
Reality is fundamentally mental.
ADVERTISEMENT
View on Consciousness
Arises from physical brain functions.
A primary aspect of reality.
Historical Context
Gained prominence with modern science.
Roots in older philosophical traditions.
Relationship with Science
Aligns with empirical methods.
Often contrasts with empirical findings.
Primary Entities
Material objects and physical properties.
Ideas, consciousness, or spiritual entities.
Physicalism and Idealism Definitions
Physicalism
The belief that everything is fundamentally physical.
Physicalism dominates much of contemporary scientific thought.
ADVERTISEMENT
Idealism
The mind or consciousness is primary.
Idealism holds that the external world is a manifestation of the mind.
Physicalism
Consciousness and thoughts have physical bases.
Physicalism seeks to understand consciousness through brain activity.
Idealism
Often contrasts with empirical findings.
Idealism can challenge empirical understandings of the world.
Physicalism
All phenomena can be reduced to physical entities.
Physicalism reduces mental states to brain states.
Idealism
Reality is constructed by mental activities.
Idealism views the mind as a central constructor of reality.
Physicalism
Only physical entities and properties exist.
Physicalism excludes non-material explanations for phenomena.
Idealism
Reality is rooted in mental or spiritual entities.
Plato's forms are an early example of Idealism.
Physicalism
Closely aligns with empirical science.
Physicalism supports the methodologies of modern science.
Idealism
Prioritizes non-physical entities like ideas.
Berkeley's Idealism posited that objects exist as perceptions.
Physicalism
The doctrine that all that exists is ultimately physical.
Idealism
The act or practice of envisioning things in an ideal and often impractical form.
Physicalism
(philosophy) A philosophical position holding that everything which exists is no more extensive than its physical properties; that is, that there are no kinds of things other than physical things, which all are of logically procedural nature, based on fundamental laws at their deepest level of causality.
Idealism
Pursuit of one's ideals, often without regard to practical ends.
Physicalism
(philosophy) the philosophical theory that matter is the only reality
Idealism
Idealized treatment of a subject in literature or art.
Idealism
(Philosophy) The theory that the object of external perception, in itself or as perceived, consists of ideas.
Idealism
The property of a person of having high ideals that are usually unrealizable or at odds with practical life.
Idealism
The practice or habit of giving or attributing ideal form or character to things; treatment of things in art or literature according to ideal standards or patterns;—opposed to realism.
Idealism
(philosophy) An approach to philosophical enquiry, which asserts that direct and immediate knowledge can only be had of ideas or mental pictures.
Idealism
The quality or state of being ideal.
Idealism
Conception of the ideal; imagery.
Idealism
The system or theory that denies the existence of material bodies, and teaches that we have no rational grounds to believe in the reality of anything but ideas and their relations.
Idealism
The practice or habit of giving or attributing ideal form or character to things; treatment of things in art or literature according to ideal standards or patterns; - opposed to realism.
Idealism
A belief in the feasibility of the implementation of ideal principles and noble goals, and the practice or habit of pursuing such goals; - opposed to realism and cynicism.
Idealism
(philosophy) the philosophical theory that ideas are the only reality
Idealism
Impracticality by virtue of thinking of things in their ideal form rather than as they really are
Idealism
Elevated ideals or conduct; the quality of believing that ideals should be pursued
FAQs
Can someone be both a Physicalist and an Idealist?
Typically not, as they present opposing views on the nature of reality.
Is Physicalism synonymous with Materialism?
They are closely related, but Physicalism is broader, encompassing all physical entities, not just material.
Do Physicalists deny the existence of the mind?
No, but they believe the mind has a physical basis, typically in the brain.
Has science proven Physicalism?
Science supports many physicalist claims, but the debate about reality's nature remains philosophical.
Do Idealists believe in a physical world?
Yes, but they see it as secondary or a manifestation of the mental.
Did Plato support Physicalism or Idealism?
Plato is often associated with Idealism, particularly with his theory of forms.
Do all scientists support Physicalism?
Most align with physicalist ideas, but not all, and many acknowledge the philosophical nature of the debate.
Is Idealism linked to religion?
While not inherently religious, some religious philosophies align with idealist concepts.
About Author
Written by
Janet WhiteJanet White has been an esteemed writer and blogger for Difference Wiki. Holding a Master's degree in Science and Medical Journalism from the prestigious Boston University, she has consistently demonstrated her expertise and passion for her field. When she's not immersed in her work, Janet relishes her time exercising, delving into a good book, and cherishing moments with friends and family.
Edited by
Aimie CarlsonAimie Carlson, holding a master's degree in English literature, is a fervent English language enthusiast. She lends her writing talents to Difference Wiki, a prominent website that specializes in comparisons, offering readers insightful analyses that both captivate and inform.
